• Home
  • Services/Classes
  • Cookbooks/Writing
  • Italy Tour
  • Travel
  • Sources/Links
  • Contact

Peanut Butter Cup Cheesecake

December 21, 2010 | Desserts,

My oldest son’s girlfriend had a birthday yesterday, and what she really wanted (other than to get carded at the bar) was a peanut butter cup cheesecake. Now my oldest son is hardly a cook – he basically eats white food only – and he’s certainly not a baker. But see what romance can inspire? He spent the afternoon in the kitchen with me yesterday baking this for his girl. Aw, sweet, right?! We made a simple crust out of crushed chocolate graham crackers and butter and pressed that into a springform pan.Next, we whipped up cream cheese that was at room temperature……then whipped in a can of sweetened condensed milk.The batter should be perfectly smooth like this.After nearly starting a fire by trying to melt chocolate in the microwave (I should know better!) we did it properly over a hot water bath on the stove.When it’s completely smooth like this it gets whipped into the cheesecake mixture……followed by eggs, beaten in one at a time.Finally, we folded in the quartered mini Reese’s peanut butter cups……saving a few to adorn the top. I’m sorry I can’t share the final product, as my son took it with him as soon as he pulled it out of the oven. But he did text me a photo late last night showing the cheesecake unmolded and decorated with a some chocolate syrup drizzled back and forth over the top – cute! I managed to download my son’s photo from his phone to touch up a bit -it’s not he greatest photo, but you get the idea of how it looked – and I hope he earned a few points with his girlfriend!

Peanut Butter Cup Cheesecake
Serves 16

2 cups graham cracker crumbs, regular or chocolate
10 tablespoons butter, melted
1/4 cup sugar
2 pounds cream cheese, softened
1 can sweetened condensed milk
1 1/4 cups chocolate chips, melted
4 large eggs
32 peanut butter cup candies, bite sized, quartered

Preheat oven to 300 degrees. Fill a pan with hot water and put it in the oven on the bottom rack. Line the bottom of a spring-form pan with foil, then wrap the pan up the sides in foil to ensure no cheesecake leaks out while cooking. Combine cracker crumbs with melted butter and sugar, stir together, then press into the pan, coming just slightly up the edges with the crumbs. Beat cream cheese until soft and fluffy; add milk and beat until incorporated. Add melted chocolate and beat until smooth, then add eggs one at a time, beating until well blended. Fold in all but 1/2 cup of the peanut butter cups then pour into the prepared spring-form pan. Dot the top of the cheesecake with remaining peanut butter candies and bake for 60-70 minutes, until cake is set (center may remain a bit wiggly but will firm up as it cools). Cool completely and refrigerate before cutting.


2 Responses | TrackBack URL | Comments Feed

  1. Wow, this looks amazing!! Would love to have a huge piece of this yummy-looking cake!! You should consider entering this cake into http://www.recipe4living.com/articles/the_recipe4living_5th_birthday_recipe_contest_sponsored_by_scharffen_berger.htm – Recipe4Living’s 5th Birthday Recipe Contest! The site is turning 5 years old, and we’re giving away a Scharffen Berger gift basket to the top birthday cake that’s submitted!


  2. Your blog is lovely! This cheesecake looks fantastic, I am definetly going to give it a try sometime.


Leave a Reply

About Michele

My Cookbooks


Profile in Colorado Homes & Lifestyles

CHL with books 7-2014

Restaurant Reviews

  • izakaya den
  • dining out tip
  • ThinkstockPhotos-503528737
  • squeaky bean denver salmon with radishes 1
  • Chefs Up Front 2011
  • sushi den sashimi lunch
  • stoic and genuine denver oysters-1

Ingredient Search

almonds apples arugula Asian asparagus avocado bacon baking balsamic barbecue basil beans bechamel beef beets bison blueberries braising broccoli brunch butter buttermilk cabbage cake carrots cauliflower celeriac celery cheese chicken chickpeas chiles chili chocolate Christmas cilantro coconut cookbook cookies Cooking Matters Colorado corn couscous cranberries CSA cucumber curry dips duck eggplant eggs fennel feta cheese fish gardens garlic ginger giveaway goat cheese grains greens grilling herbs ice cream Italian kale lamb lasagna leeks leftovers lemon lime meatballs meatloaf Mexican mint Moroccan muffins mushrooms mussels nuts oats olive oil onions orange pancetta parsley peach pears peppers pesto pickles pineapple pine nuts pizza plums pork potatoes prosciutto quinoa ribs rice ricotta roasting rosemary salmon sausage Share Our Strength shrimp soy spaghetti Spanish spices spinach squash stews strawberries sushi sweet potatoes swiss chard tarragon Thanksgiving tomatoes tortillas tuna turkey vegetarian vinegar wine yogurt zucchini


Click on the Door to Door Organics logo above to sign up for delivery and receive 10% off your first order!

Help End Hunger


Other Stuff

Cooking with Michele

my foodgawker gallery

Sommelier Courses and Wine Classes from the International Wine Guild Wine School

The International Wine Guild Wine School